Wild Plants of Central Kazakhstan with
Antibiotic Properties and Effect
Yelena Pozdnyakova*†, Gulnara Omarova†
and Aigul Murzatayeva†
Department of Biomedicine, Karaganda Medical University,
Karaganda 100011, Kazakhstan
*For correspondence: nike_anteros@mail.ru
†Contributed equally to this work and are co-first
authors
Received 22 February 2022; Accepted 21 March 2022;
Published 30 April 2022
Abstract
This article presents the results of field studies of the biological
diversity of wild plants with antibiotic properties growing in the climatic
conditions of Central Kazakhstan. As a result of the field studies, 28 plant species
with antibiotic properties belonging to 26 families were found. Among them, the
most numerous are from Asteraceae
family – 8 species and the Lamiaceae
family – 6 species. The rest of the plant species were distributed according to
the principle “one species - one family”. These plants have enormous
potential for health, but mainly grow locally or are scattered in small groups
and do not form thickets of commercial value in nature. We also conducted a
survey among two
age groups – 18 to 25 years old and 35 to 55 years old. The survey showed that
the older generation is more aware of plant species with antibiotic properties
and is more willing to choose natural herbs. The second group knows only those
types of plants that are part of the famous syrups and lozenges for colds.
Based on the above data, it can be concluded that a sufficient number of plants
with antibiotic properties grow in the territory of Central Kazakhstan. Given
their low cost and availability, we believe that they need to be popularized
among the younger generation and recommended for commercial use. © 2022 Friends Science Publishers
Keywords: Antibiotic plants; Biodiversity;
Central Kazakhstan; Medicinal plants
Introduction
A global health crisis is currently brewing due to an increase in the
number of multidrug-resistant (MDR) microorganisms as it causes antimicrobial
resistance (World Health Organization Antimicrobial Resistance 2014). Antibiotics are widely
prescribed in the early stages of disease and have recently been used to treat
a wide range of infections. The COVID-19 pandemic has increased the consumption
of antibiotics and, as a consequence, this has led to an increase in resistance
in a large number of people (Rawson et al. 2020). Traditionally, medicinal herbs have been used to treat viral and
bacterial infections and recently, scientists have been constantly trying to
discover new micro-components isolated from medicinal plants. The side effects
of available antibiotics and microbial resistance are the main reasons for
looking for alternative herbal antibiotics. Plant phytochemicals such as
tannins, alkaloids, saponins, flavonoids, polyphenols and glycosides can be
considered to act as antibacterial agents (Roca et al. 2015).
Currently, the exact composition and mechanisms of action of herbal
medicines are still not well understood. However, it is already known that
plant components can act as immunomodulators, be a source of antioxidant
compounds, prevent the attachment of microbes and the formation of a bacterial
film, and also stop the proliferation or reproduction of microorganisms (Akram et al. 2020). The antibacterial activity
of plants is a subject of interest in the search for new antibiotics and
fungicidal preparations. An important area of modern medicine is the search for
new substances and strategies for combating infectious diseases, which pose an
increasing threat due to the growth of bacterial resistance to antibiotics. The
increase in strains of multidrug-resistant pathogens has led to extensive
phytochemical and pharmacological research (Tacconelli et al. 2018).
Recent events related to the necessary isolation of countries and
continents have led to the need not only to search for new sources of plant
materials with antibacterial and antiviral effects, but also to use local
plants with a similar effect. The purpose of this study is to study the
biological diversity of wild plants with an antibiotic effect growing in the
territory of Central Kazakhstan, as well as to assess the effectiveness of
their use as medicines among the local population.
Materials and Methods
This study was performed as part of the traditional summer practice of
biology students in the period of July–August 2019. The main method used in the
field studies was route exploration. The route ran in the Karkaraly National
Park, the eastern part of the Kazakh Upland. The route coordinates covered the
radius of 49°18'7 2"N 75°29'18 24"E and 49°17'41 28"N75°32'19
68"E. (Fig. 1.) This territory has all
Fig. 1: Territory of the field research route
Fig. 2: Natural areas of the territory of the field studies route
the characteristics inherent in the landscape of the entire Central
Kazakhstan. There are steppe, forest-steppe and forest zones here (Fig. 2).
There are flood-meadows between the hills, where moisture accumulates during
the melting of snows, and at the same time there are steppes open to the sun
and winds. The soils are brown, saline red-brown and saline. Basically, stony
and stony and gravelly soils prevail.
The climate here, as in all of Central Kazakhstan, is arid, sharply
continental. This is reflected in the severity of winter, high summer
temperatures, short duration of spring and autumn, dry air and low rainfall.
Due to this, the species diversity of plants is quite small. According to the literature,
about 850 species of flowering plants belonging to 78 families grow in this
territory (Karaganda region Encyclopedia 1986).
While carrying out the research, classical botanical research methods
were used. Laboratory processing of the source material was carried out in
strict accordance with all requirements, and herbarium samples were stored in
the herbarium collection of Karaganda Medical University. To identify the
collected materials, the main floristic annotations covering the territory of Kazakhstan
(Baitenov 1999, 2001) were followed. The study of the medicinal value of the
found plants was carried out using the Google Scholar, Medline and Scopus
databases. The search was carried out using various keywords, for example,
“medicinal plants”, “plants with antibacterial activity”, “plants of Central
Asia”. The search included literature published over a five-year period (to the
extent possible) up to May 2021.
We also conducted a survey among two age groups: 1st group
18–25 years old and 2nd group 35–55 years old. The respondents
received from us a list of antibiotic plants growing in the territory of
Central Kazakhstan and answered two questions Do you know that this plant has
antibiotic properties?” and “Do you use this plant as a source of antibiotics
for the corresponding diseases? In total, about 120 people participated; 60 for
each group.
Results
Biodiversity of antibiotic
plants in central kazakhstan
The 28 species of antibiotic plants that we discovered contain a large
amount of active substances (Table 1). As a result of the conducted field
studies, the following plant species with antibiotic effect were found,
collected and identified:
Table
1: Public
awareness of local antibiotic herbs
Species |
Local name |
1st group |
2nd group |
C. cyanus |
Júgeri
gúli kók |
U(100%)/D (100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
T. farfara |
Ógeıshóp |
K(80%)/M(40%) |
K(95%)/M(78%) |
H. arenarium |
Salaýbas |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
I. helenium |
Bıik
andyz |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K(35%)/M(10%) |
C. officinalis |
Dárilik
qyrmyzygúl |
K(90%)/M(40%) |
K(100%)/M(80%) |
A. absinthium |
Ashy
jýsan |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K(45%)/D(3%) |
M. chamomilla |
Dárilik
túımedaq |
K(100%)/M(70%) |
K(100%)/M(90%) |
G. uliginosum |
Aq shaıyr |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
A. millefolium |
Kádimgi
myńjapyraq |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K(92%)/M(73%) |
S. officinālis |
Shatyrash |
K(90%)/M(87%) |
K(100%)/M(93%) |
M. piperita |
Jalbyz |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
T. vulgaris |
Tasshóp |
K(40%)/M(10%) |
K(83%)/M(37%) |
T. serpyllum |
Tasshóp |
K(40%)/M(10%) |
K(83%)/M(37%) |
O. vulgare |
Kádimgi jupargúl |
U(100%)/D (100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
H. officinalis |
Kók shaıqýraı |
U(100%)/D (100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
A. calamus |
Andyz |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
L. palustre |
Saz qazanaq |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
S. nigra |
Qara badam |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K (10%) /M (3%) |
B. crassifolia |
Badan qalyń japyraqty |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
B. pendula |
Qaıyń |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
P. aviculare |
Qus taran |
K(30%)/M(15%) |
K(87%)/M(70%) |
G. lutea |
- |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
D. superbus |
Qalampyr |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K (7%)/M (1%) |
H. perforatum |
Shaıqýraı |
K(35%)/М(10%) |
K(83%)/M(65%) |
M. officinalis |
Dári túıejońyshqa |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
K(20%)/M(5%) |
C. majus |
Súıelshóp |
K(85%)/M(3%) |
K(100%)/M(30%) |
R. confertus |
At
kýlak / Jylky kymyzdyk |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
U(100%)/D(100%) |
J. communis |
Kádimgi
arsha |
K(30%)/D(100%) |
K(68%)/M (20%) |
K – known, U –
unknown, M – use as medicine, D – do not use as medicine
Centaurea
cyanus L.: An annual,
biennial meadow herb of the Asteraceae family. Ethyl acetate extract and
aqueous extracts of C. cyanus exhibit
antibacterial activity against three gram-positive bacteria Staphylococcus aureus (food isolate), S. aureus, Listeria monocytogenes (clinical isolate) in the experiment (Haziri
et al. 2017).
Tussilago farfara L.: A perennial herb of the family. It has a wide range of
pharmacological effects and has an effect on the respiratory, cardiovascular
and digestive systems, as well as antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and
neuroprotective effects (Liu et al.
2020). Its essential oil has antibacterial activity against E. coli and S. Aureus (Boucher
et al. 2020).
Helichrysum arenarium (L.) Moench.: A herbaceous perennial plant of
the Asteraceae family, its flowers have a long tradition of use in European
ethnomedicine as a choleretic, hepatoprotective and detoxifying herbal medicine
(Pljevljakušić et
al. 2018). The bacteriostatic and bactericidal activity of the alcoholic extract of
dry flowers of H. arenarium prepared
according to a special method was studied in vitro against Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The experiment revealed that
Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains resistant to reference drugs were
susceptible to H. arenarium extract (Skvortsova et al. 2015).
Inula
helenium L.: Perennial plant species of the Asteraceae
family. I. helenium has a
choleretic, expectorant, fungicidal, bactericidal and antiviral effect. I. helenium has antimicrobial activity
against three strains of bacteria e.g.,
Enterococcus hirae, Escherichia coli and S. aureus (Coss et al. 2018). The chemical components of I. helenium have a strong inhibitory
effect on E. coli, S. aureus and Bacillus subtilis (Bai et al.
2018). I. helenium is a valuable
source of active compounds with anti-inflammatory activity and justifies its
traditional use in the treatment of inflammatory diseases of the respiratory
tract (Gierlikowska et al. 2020).
Calendula
officinalis L.: An annual plant of the Asteraceae
family. Studies of C. officinalis show
that it has anti-inflammatory and antibacterial activity, as well as angiogenic
and fibroplastic properties, positively affecting the inflammatory and
proliferative phases of the wound healing process (Parente et al. 2012). C.
officinalis is effective for treating bacterial vaginosis in women of
reproductive age without any side effects. This herb is recommended for women
of reproductive age who cannot use synthetic drugs due to their potential side
effects
(Najafi 2019).
Artemisia
absinthium L.: A perennial plant of the Asteraceae
family. As a result of the study, A.
absinthium was found to have antiviral effect against the hepatitis B virus
in the treatment of chronic hepatitis B (Ansari et al. 2018). Extracts of A.
absinthium exhibit strong larvicidal activity against mosquitoes that
transmit malaria, dengue and filariasis (Ali et al.
2018). Also, A. absinthium extract shows an
antioxidant effect, exhibits cytotoxic activity against DLD-1 and ECC-1 cancer
cells (Koyuncu 2018).
Matricaria
chamomilla L.: An annual plant from the Asteraceae
family, it has been used as a source of antimicrobial drugs for a long time (Sharifi-Rad et al. 2018). It is used in dentistry to
treat gingivitis (Safiaghdam et al.
2018). It also has
antioxidant properties (Amraei et al.
2018). Phytoisolates
of M. chamomilla show the ability to
produce antifungal agents, its extracts inhibit the growth of important human
pathogens: Candida krusei, C.
parapsilosis and C. glabrata
(Mojicevic et al. 2019). The research
results demonstrated that the peptide MCh-AMP1 derived from M. chamomilla causes death of C. albicans cells by increasing the
permeability of the cell membrane and inducing ROS production (Seyedjavadi et al. 2019).
Gnaphalium
uliginosum L.: An annual plant from the Asteraceae
family, widely used in Russian and Bulgarian herbal medicine in the treatment
of hypertension, thrombophlebitis, phlebothrombosis and ulcers. It is known
that the decoction and infusion of G.
uliginosum have anti-inflammatory, astringent and antiseptic properties.
Oil extracts are used in the treatment of laryngitis, upper respiratory catarrh
and tonsillitis (Shikov et al.
2010). The ethanol
extract of G. uliginosum has moderate
antimicrobial activity against S. aureus,
B. cereus and A. solani. G. uliginosum
essential oil is considered a weak antioxidant (Leonidovna et al. 2019).
Achillea
millefolium L.: A perennial plant from the Asteraceae
family, A. millefolium has
anti-inflammatory, wound healing, and antimicrobial effects (Hajisalem et al. 2019).
Sālvia
officinālis L.: A perennial subshrub of the Lamiaceae family. S. officinalis extract showed high
antibacterial activity on clinical samples isolated from the oral cavity – S. aureus, S. epidermidis, Streptococcus
mutans, C. albicans, C. tropicalis and
C. glabrata (De Oliveira et al.
2019). Also,
mouthwash with S. officinalis solution
effectively reduces the amount of S.
mutans in plaque (Beheshti-Rouy et
al. 2015).
Mentha
piperita L.: A perennial plant of the Lamiaceae family. Its essential oil exhibits
significant antibacterial (against S.
aureus, Micrococcus flavus, B. subtilis, S. epidermidis and Salmonella enteritides) and antifungal
(against Alternaria alternata, Fusarium
tabacinum, Penicillum spp., F. oxyporum and Aspergillus sp.)
activity (Desam et al. 2019).
Thymus
vulgaris L.: A perennial shrub of the Lamiaceae family is an important source of
medicinal substances with antioxidant, antimicrobial, antitumor and cytotoxic
properties (Hameed et al. 2018). The essential oil obtained from
T. vulgaris contains a large amount
of flavonoids, has antioxidant and antimicrobial activity. Therefore, it can be
used as a good source in the development of new natural antioxidants and
antibiotics (Almanea et al. 2019). The alcoholic extract of T. vulgaris has shown excellent
antibacterial activity against the gram-positive bacterium S. aureus and this extract can be used to target pathogenic
bacteria, in particular acne formation (Mohammed et al. 2020). Research results support the use of T. vulgaris essential oil as an
alternative or adjunctive treatment for multidrug-resistant bacteria infections
and for preventing biofilm formation and quorum signaling. It can be used as a
safe antioxidant (Alibi et al.
2020).
Thymus
serpyllum L.: A perennial subshrub of the Lamiaceae family. T. serpyllum oil
has antirheumatic,
antiseptic, antispasmodic, antimicrobial, cardiac, carminative, diuretic and
expectorant properties. The oil is also good for strengthening the immune
system and helps fight colds, flu, infections, and chills. It has been proven
to be a urinary antiseptic, very useful in the treatment of cystitis and
urethritis (Nikolić et al.
2014). The
essential oil obtained from T. serpyllum
has antimicrobial activity against the E.
coli strain and against the yeast C.
albicans (Wesolowska et al. 2015).
Origanum
vulgare L.: A perennial plant of the Lamiaceae
family. Research results indicate a high antioxidant and antibacterial
activity of O. vulgare against
ampicillin-resistant E. coli. (Moghrovyan et al. 2019). Hydroalcoholic extract from O. vulgare stimulates antimycobacterial
innate immunity and limits the inflammatory response in vitro (De Santis et al. 2019).
Hyssopus
officinalis L.: A subshrub of the Lamiaceae family,
H. officinalis is on the list of herbs with
potential to fight HIV/AIDS, but more research is needed (Laila et
al. 2019).
Acorus
calamus L.: A perennial plant of the Araceae
family. It has an insecticidal, antifungal, antibacterial,
tranquilizing, antidiarrheal, antidyslipidemic, neuroprotective, antioxidant,
anticholinesterase, antispasmodic, vascular modulator effect (Mohammed and
Hameed 2018). It is currently being investigated as a new antiviral candidate
for dengue fever (Rosmalena et al.
2019). Studies have been carried out to prove the effectiveness of plant
rhizome extracts against nosocomial strains of B. subtilis, E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Vibrio cholerae (Nayak et al. 2017).
Ledum
palustre L.: An evergreen shrub from the Ericaceae
family, found in peatlands in Northern Europe, Asia and North America.
For about 200 years, it has been used in ethnomedicine to treat various
diseases such as rheumatism, coughs, and colds (Dampc and Luczkiewicz 2013).
Sambucus
nigra L. A deciduous shrub of the Adoxaceae
family, traditionally used to treat flu and colds. Oral administration
of high molecular weight fractions of S.
nigra to mice infected with human influenza A virus (IFV) inhibits viral
replication and increases serum IFV-specific neutralizing antibodies (Kinoshita et al. 2012). New experimental data also
confirm that S. nigra extracts block
viral effects (Torabian et al.
2019). S. nigra flavonoids bind and prevent
H1N1 infection in vitro by binding to H1N1 virions, blocking host cell entry
and/or recognition (Roschek et al.
2009). S. nigra (as an extract or lozenge) can
reduce flu symptoms, including fever, headache, nasal congestion, and nasal
discharge in adults when taken within the first 48 h of symptom onset
(Przybylska-Balcerek et al. 2021).
Bergenia
crassifolia (L.) Fritsch.: A perennial herb of the Saxifragaceae family, it has
hemostatic, anti-inflammatory and antimicrobial properties (Żbikowska
et al. 2017). B. crassifolia leaf extract exhibits antibacterial, antiviral, antitumor,
antidiabetic, diuretic and immunostimulating activity (Tumova et al. 2018).
Betula
pendula Roth.: A species of woody plants of the Betulaceae
family. Studies have shown that B.
pendula bud extract has activity against Quorum Sensing – the ability of
some bacteria to communicate and coordinate their behavior through the
secretion of molecular signals (Tolmacheva et
al. 2014). An aqueous extract of B.
pendula birch leaves inhibits the growth and division of inflammatory
lymphocyte cells (Gründemann et al.
2011). Dried birch leaf extract has a relatively high antioxidant potential and
can be used as a natural source of antioxidants (Penkov et al. 2018).
Polygonum aviculare L.: An annual plant of the Polygonаceae family.
Its extracts show significant antimicrobial properties against
gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria, as well as mycobacteria (tuberculous
and non-tuberculous mycobacteria) (Millar et
al. 2021). P. aviculare extracts
also have wound healing and antioxidant properties (Seo et al. 2016).
Gentiana lutea L.: A perennial plant of the Gentianaceae family. Methanol extracts of its flowers and leaves have shown
antimicrobial activity against a variety of gram-positive and gram-negative
bacteria, as well as the yeast C.
albicans (Savikin et al. 2009). G. lutea has antioxidant,
anti-inflammatory, antimitogenic, antiproliferative and hypolipidemic effects,
as well as cardioprotective, hypotensive, vasodilatory and antiplatelet effects
(Jiang et al. 2021).
Dianthus
superbus L.: A species of perennial herbs of the Caryophyllaceae family.
Molecular studies have shown that quercetin 3-rutinoside and isorhamnetin
3-glucoside, abundant in D. superbus,
have shown strong antiviral activity against influenza A and B viruses,
providing a new line of research to develop possible natural anti-influenza
drugs (Nile et al. 2020).
Hypericum
perforatum L. A perennial herb from the Hypericaceae
family that has long been used as a traditional treatment for skin wounds,
burns, cuts and stomach ailments, including abdominal pain and ulcers. Recent
studies have shown its properties to inhibit antiquorum sensitivity (anti-QS)
and antibiofilm activity (Doğan et al.
2019). Its active
components hypericin naphthodianthrone and hyperforin phloroglucinol are
effective antibacterial compounds against various gram-positive bacteria (Lyles et al. 2017). The results of in vitro
experiments confirmed that the antiviral component of H. perforatum significantly reduces the relative expression of
ribonucleic acid (mRNA) and infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) titer (Chen et al. 2019).
Melilotus
officinalis (L.) Lam.: A biennial herb of the Fabaceae
family. In a study of M. officinalis
extracts for antimicrobial, antioxidant and antibiofilm activity, the results
show a greater effect on gram-positive bacteria than on gram-negative bacteria.
Acetone extract of M. officinalis
inhibits the formation of biofilms of bacteria Proteus mirabilis and P.
aeruginosa. M. officinalis
aqueous extract has high antioxidant activity. The flavonoid compounds in M. officinalis have antioxidant and
anti-inflammatory properties (Khosroyar and Arastehnodeh 2018).
Chelidonium
majus L.: A perennial plant of the Papaveraceae family. The latex of the herb C. majus has been used in folk medicine
for many years to treat viral warts. It has been experimentally shown that C. majus may be a potential remedy for
skin warts, especially in younger patients where conventional therapy can be
difficult to apply (Nawrot et al.
2020).
Rumex
confertus Willd.: A perennial
plant of the Polygonaceae family. Studies have shown that R. confertus extracts have a
differential inhibitory effect on the growth of gram-positive bacteria –
staphylococci – and gram-negative bacteria – E. coli, P. mirabilis, P. aeruginosa (Wegiera et al. 2011). R. confertus fruit extracts showed moderate
activity against Candida spp. and Trichophyton mentagrophytes. The data
obtained indicate that the fruit of R.
confertus can be considered as an alternative or adjuvant in the treatment
of superficial mycoses (Kosikowska et al.
2011).
Juniperus
communis L.: An evergreen coniferous shrub of the Cupressaceae family. It is used in several traditional medicinal
systems for the treatment of various diseases, including rheumatism, arthritis
and gout (Fernandez and Cock 2016). The hydroalcoholic extract obtained from J. communis has genoprotective, antioxidant, antifungal and
anti-inflammatory properties (Fierascu et al.
2018). As a result of
resource studies of the study area, it was found that most species of
antibiotic plants grow near roads, in meadows and forest zones and have the
status of weeds. The greatest floristic diversity was noted in flood-meadows
and areas where the soils are sufficiently moist. The quantitative distribution
of the plants found by us by families is extremely uneven. Of the 28 found and identified
plant species, 8 species belong to the Asteraceae
family, and 6 species belong to the Lamiaceae family. The rest of the plant species were distributed
according to the principle “one species – one family”.
Some of the
antibiotic plants we found, according to the pharmacopoeial publications (State Register of Medicines of the
Republic of Kazakhstan 2001), are used in
Kazakhstan as part of preparations for the treatment of cholecystitis, gastritis,
insomnia, diseases of the stomach, liver, intestines, and brain function. Also,
they are used as analgesics, for the treatment of helminthiasis, stomatitis,
tonsillitis, wounds, ulcers, hemorrhoids and other diseases. But the majority
of species of antibiotic plants, as our research has shown, do not form
thickets of commercial value in nature. Some species are found locally or
scattered. Some species grow in hard-to-reach, swampy places and in alpine
conditions, some, like ruderal plants, grow near roads, in settlements, on
fallow lands, etc. Therefore, many of them are cultivated and this covers the
need for raw materials.
Public awareness of local antibiotic herbs
As a result of the analysis of the
survey of the two age groups, the results were obtained, and the prevailing
answer options are presented in Table 2. Based on the survey analysis results,
it was evident that the population is poorly aware of local Table 2: Phytochemical components of antibiotic plants of
Central Kazakhstan
Species |
Phytochemical Constituents |
C. cyanus |
Flowers: anthocyanin glycosides (cyanidin and pelargonidin
diglucosides), flavones glycosides (apigenin and luteolin derivatives),
flavonols (quercetin glucoside, 3-methyl-kaempferol, rutin, cicornin),
vitamin C, carotene, tannins, essential oil, mucus, polyacetylene compounds
(Lockowandt et al. 2019). |
T. farfara |
Leaves saponins, inulin, bitter glucoside tussilagin,
tannins, ascorbic acid, carotenoid, gallic, malic and tartaric acids,
sitosterol, dextrins, essential oil, flavonoids (Uysal et al. 2019). |
H. arenarium |
Inflorescences and leaves: flavonoid glycosides (salipurposide, kaempferol
and isosalipurposide), flavonoids (naringenin and apigenin) (Morikawa et al. 2009). Inflorescences: phthalides, steroid
compounds, dyes, essential oil, inositol, tannins, fatty acids, mineral salts
(Czinner et al. 2000). |
I. helenium |
Rhizome: inulin, bitter substances, essential oil, saponins,
resins, gum, a small amount of alkaloids, gelenin (Lunz and Stappen, 2021). Essential
oil: allantolactone (proazulene, gelenin), resins, dihydroalantolactone,
fridelin, stigmastern, phytomelan, pectins, wax, gum, vitamin E. Leaves: flavonoids, vitamins
(ascorbic acid, tocopherol), bitter substances, tannins, lactones, fumaric,
acetic, propionic acids (Bai et al. 2018). |
C. officinalis |
Flowers: carotenoids and flavonoids (carotene, lycopene,
violaxanthin, citraxanthin, rubixanthin, flavoxanthin, flavochrome). Inflorescences: polysaccharides,
polyphenols, resins, organic acids (malic, ascorbic and traces of salicylic
acid) (Mlcek et al. 2021). Herb:
up to 10% bitter substance calendene, triterpene saponin. In seeds: fatty oil
(lauric and palmitic acids). In roots:
inulin and a number of triterpene glycosides (derivatives of oleanolic acid)
(Ak et al. 2021). |
A. absinthium |
Herb: sesquiterpene lactones, bitter glycosides
(absinthine, anabsinthine, artabsin and artemisetin), saponins, flavonoids,
phytoncides, ascorbic acid, resinous and tanning substances, potassium salts,
artemisetin, carotene, organic acids (malic, succinic) (Szopa et al. 2020). Essential oil: thuyl alcohol (up to
10-25%), thujone (up to 10%), pinene, cadinene, phellandrene,
β-caryophyllene, γ-selinene, β-bisabolene, curcumene and
chamazulenogen (Ickovski et al. 2021). |
M. chamomilla |
Inflorescences: chamazulene, sequiterpene carbohydrates – farnesene
and cadinene, sequiterpene alcohols – bisabolol, caprylic acid, sequiterpene
lactones matricin and matricarin (Aćimović et al. 2021a). In
addition, the inflorescences contain: carbohydrates and related compounds
(pectic acid, xylose, arabinose, galactose, rhamnose, glucuronic acid),
choline, polyacetylenic compounds, phenolcarboxylic acids and their
derivatives (anisic, vanillic, syringic, chlorogenic, salicylic, caffeic
acids), tannins, coumarins (umbelliferone, herniarin), flavonoids (apigenin,
luteolin, quercetin, isorhamnetin, chrysoeriol, patuletin, cynaroside)
(Bhukta et al. 2021). |
G. uliginosum |
Herb: flavonoids (gnafalosides A and B, luteolin,
scutellarein, scutellarein glycoside, rutin, tricine, eupafolin, quercetin),
chlorogenic and caffeic acids, carotenoids, as well as vitamin C, thiamine,
resins, tannins, coumarins, alkaloids (gnafalin), essential oil,
phytosterols, ascorbic acid (Olennikov et al. 2015). |
A. millefolium |
Herb: flavones, achillein alkaloid, coumarins, aconitic
acid, bitter substances and tannins, resins, organic acids, inulin,
asparagine, mineral salts, ascorbic acid, phylloquinone, carotene, choline
(Benedek et al. 2007). Leaves
and inflorescences: essential oil (cineole, camphor, thujol),
sesquiterpenoids – achillin, acetylbalquinolide, caryophyllene, azulenes,
esters, L-borneol, β-pinene, L-limonene, thujone, bornylacetate,
cineole, camphor (Dias et al. 2013). |
S. officinālis |
Leaves: cineol, linalool, α- and β-pinene,
borneol, thujone, linalyl acetate and other terpene compounds, tannins,
vitamins P and PP; flavonoids: hispidulin, genquanin, 6-methoxygenquinine,
salvitin, luteolin, 6-hydroxyluteolin, cirziliol, cynaroside, nepetine;
alkaloids, resinous substances; triterpenoids: ursolic and oleanolic acids;
diterpene salvin; phenolcarboxylic acids: chlorogenic, noochlorogenic,
cryptochlorogenic, caffeic, rosmarinic; bitter principles, phytoncides
(Turkmen 2021) |
M. piperita |
Essential oil: menthol (40–70%) and its esters, β-pinene,
limonene, cineole, dipentene, pulegone and other terpenoids. Inflorescence
oil also contains menthol, α-pinene, β-pinene, menthofuran,
pulegone, sabinene hydrate, pereric acid (Motiee 2021). Leaves: organic acids, tannins, flavonoids, carotene, betaine,
hesperidin, ursolic and oleanolic acids (Wu et
al. 2019). |
T. vulgaris |
Herb: thymol and liquid carvacrol, cymol, borneol,
pinene, terpinene, terpineol, tannins, ursolic, caffeic, chlorogenic and
oleanolic acids, flavonoids, bitter principles and mineral salts (Popa et al. 2021). |
T. serpyllum |
Herb: thymol, carvacol, n-cymol, a-terpineol, borneol,
tannins, bitter principles, gum, triterpene compounds (ursolic and oleanoic
acids), flavonoids (Malankina et al. 2019) |
O. vulgare |
Herb: thymol (up to 40%), cymol, carvacrol,
sesquiterpenes, geranyl acetate, selinene, α-thujone, α-,
flavonoids: apigenin, luteolin, 7-glucuronide, luteolin-7-glucoside,
isoroifolin, cosmosiin; ascorbic acid and tannins (Zhao et al. 2021). |
H. officinalis |
Herb: triterpenic acids (oleanolic and ursolic), tannins
and bitter substances, resins, gums, pigments. Essential oil: 1-pinocamphone, α-pinene (1%), β-pinene
(5%), cineole, camphene, 1-pinocampheol and its acetic ester, sesquiterpenes
(Aćimović et al. 2021b). |
A. calamus |
Rhizomes: monoterpenes (camphene, camphor, borneol) and
sesquiterpenes (acorone, isoacorone, acoroxide, etc.), aromatic compounds
(azaron, eugenol), bitter glycoside acorin, bitter principle acoretin,
tannins, ascorbic and palmitic acids, starch, choline, vitamins, iodine. The
smell of rhizomes is due to azarylaldehyde (Chellakannu and Paneerselvam 2020). |
L. palustre |
Herb: ledol, palustrol, η-cymol, geranyl acetate,
glucosides (ericolin, arbutin); andromedotoxin; coumarins (esculin,
esculetin, scopoletin, umbelliferon etc.), flavonoids (quercetin,
hyperoside); tannins; phytoncides; vitamin C; dyes; micro and macro elements
(Zhao et al. 2017). |
S. nigra |
Flowers: flavonoids, organic acids (malic, acetic, valeric,
chlorogenic), terpenes, sambunigrin glucoside, sambucin, rutin; essential
oil, vitamin C, antiseptics – benzaldehyde and cynates. Fruits: ascorbic acid, glucose, fructose, malic acid, vitamin C,
tannins, carotene, anthocyanin. Unripe fruits contain the poisonous glycoside
sambunigrin (breaks down into hydrocyanic acid and benzaldehyde)
(Radojković et al. 2021). |
B. crassifolia |
Rhizomes: tannins, phenolic compounds, phenolcarboxylic acids,
a coumarin derivative – bergenin, isocoumarins, catechins, starch, sugars,
mineral salts. Leaves: gallic
acid, coumarins, flavonoids, vitamin C, carotene and arbutin, plus 2-4% free
hydroquinone (Akzhigitova et al. 2020). |
B. pendula |
Buds essential oil: betulin, betulol, betulenolic acid. Leaves: betuloretinic acid, ascorbic
acid, carotene, triterpene alcohols, flavonoids, leucoanthocyanides, sterols,
hyperoside, tannins, saponins (Rastogi et
al. 2015). |
P. aviculare |
Herb: tannins; flavonoids (avicularin, hyperin,
isorhamnetin, myricetin, quercetin, kaempferol), vitamins C, E, carotene;
coumarins (scopoletin, umbelliferon), phenolcarboxylic acids (gallic,
caffeic, β-coumaric, chlorogenic), anthraquinones, silicic acid
compounds (up to 4.5%), resins, mucus, fats, sugars, macronutrients:
potassium, calcium, magnesium, iron; trace elements (Seo et al. 2016). |
G. lutea |
Roots and herb: monoterpene glycosides – bitter principles
(gentiopicrin and amarogencin, gentin, gentisin, gentiamarin, gentiacaumol, gentianose),
flavonoids, gentianin alkaloids and iridoids, catechins, polysaccharides,
pectin substances, ascorbic acid, fatty oils, essential oil, tannins, mucus
and resin (Citová et al. 2008). |
D. superbus |
Herb: triterpene saponins (diantosides) and heterocyclic
oxygen compounds (3,4-dihydroxy-2-methylhydropyran and barbapyroside);
flavonoids (orientin, homoorientin), tannins (pyrocatechol derivatives),
traces of alkaloids (Yang et al. 2017) |
H. perforatum |
Herb: tannins; flavonoids (hyperoside, rutin, quercetin,
quercitrin and isoquercitrin), carotene, antibiotic hyperforin;
leukoanthocyanides and anthocyanins; cineole; resins, nicotinic and ascorbic
acids, vitamins P and PP, choline, anthocyanins, saponins, alcohols (Belwal et al. 2019). |
M. officinalis |
Herb: coumarins and their derivatives (coumarin,
dicoumarol, dihydrocoumarin, melitoside glycoside), flavonoids (robinin,
flovin, kaempferol and its derivatives), melilotin, polysaccharides (mucus),
saponins, purine derivatives (allantoin), phenolcarboxylic acids
(hydroxycinnamic, coumaric, melilotic), phenolic triterpene compounds. The
pleasant smell of the plant is given by coumarin and melilotin (Sisay et al. 2021). |
C. majus |
The plant is poisonous, contains isoquinoline alkaloids,
benzophenanthridine derivatives: homochelidonine, chelerythrine, chelidonine,
sanguinarine, protopine and others (over 20 alkaloids) (Arora and Sharma 2013). |
R. confertus |
Roots: anthraquinones (chrysophanein, glucofrangulaemodin,
rheochrysin, glucoaloe-emodin and glucorein), tannins, flavonols (quercetin
and its glycosides – hyperoside, rutin, as well as quercetin flavone bioside
– rumarin) and leukoanthocyanidins (leukoanthocyanidin, leukodelphinidin,
leukopelargonidin), phenolcarboxylic acids (caffeic, chlorogenic), citric and
lactic acid, traces of essential oil, oxycoumarins, iridoids, steroids,
resins. Leaves: anthracene
glycosides, flavonoids (hyperin, rutin), tannins, ascorbic acid, carotene,
hydroxycinnamic acids (caffeic and chlorogenic acids), oxalic acid (Tynybekov
et al. 2013). |
J. communis |
Fruits: terpenoids (α-pinene, cadinene, camphene,
α-terpinene, dipentene, sabinene, borneol, isoborneol,
α-phellandrene, juniper camphor, etc.), as well as sugars (up to 40%),
resins (up to 10%), organic acids (formic, acetic and malic), flavonoids,
pectins (pentosans), vitamin C, dyes (juniperin), fatty oil, wax and trace
elements (manganese, iron, copper and aluminum) (Orav et al. 2010). |
plants with
antibiotic effects. Thus, the respondents of the first group (18–25 years old)
recognized only banal plant species that are part of the well-known syrups and
lozenges for colds- T. farfara,
C. officinalis, S. officinālis, T. vulgaris L., H. perforatum and C. majus. But 70% of native plants with
antibiotic effect are unknown to them and they prefer pharmacological
preparations, the use of which does not take time to prepare or brew.
The second group (35–55 years old) showed greater awareness and desire
to use natural herbs as a source of antibiotics. 50% of the plants on the list
were familiar to many respondents, and they used them systematically in the
treatment of colds and viral infections (with the exception of A. absinthium because of its bitter
taste).
Discussion
Since their discovery, antimicrobial drugs have become an integral part
of modern healthcare, allowing the treatment of previously life-threatening
bacterial infections. However, the massive and irresponsible use of antibiotics
has contributed to the emergence of resistant strains. Rapid emergence of
antimicrobial resistance is now a global public health crisis and has been
named one of the most significant global public health problems by the World
Health Organization (Bianco et al. 2020). In addition, the World Health
Organization (WHO) recently updated its priority list of 12 bacterial pathogens
for which there is a need to develop new antibiotics (WHO 2017). Multidrug
resistant pathogens such as ESKAPE (e.g., E.
faecium, S. aureus, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Acinetobacter baumannii, P. aeruginosa, and Enterobacter) are considered to be virtually resistant to most
antibiotics available and play a critical role in the rise in nosocomial
infections (Ghosh and Saha
2020). The
emergence of multidrug-resistant pathogens is of great concern to the global
health community. Our ability to treat diseases effectively is based on the
discovery of powerful drugs to treat these complex diseases. Traditional
medicines are one of the main sources of search for safe, effective and
cost-effective drug candidates (Ayaz et al. 2016). In addition to the need to
find new drugs due to bacterial resistance, there has been a shortage of drugs
as a result of disruptions in the supply chain and reduced exports during the
21st century pandemic (Rusen 2020).
Mankind has used plants as medicines to treat dangerous diseases, and
they are still popular for developing new drug candidates. Plants contain a
combination of phytochemicals, also known as secondary metabolites, that occur
naturally and provide various therapeutic benefits (Sener 2020).
Studies of the biodiversity of plants with antibiotic properties in the
territory of Central Kazakhstan were carried out for the first time. As a
result of the work done, the following data were obtained: 28 plant species
with antibiotic properties belonging to 26 families grow in the territory of
Central Kazakhstan. Among them, the most numerous are the Compositae family – 8 species and the Labiatae family – 6 species. The rest of the plant species were
distributed according to the principle “one species – one family”.
Also, these plants are candidates in experiments to find new drugs for
diseases such as obesity, diabetes, oncology. For example, in experiments with
induced neuroinflammation, aqueous fraction of Acorus calamus L. caused the prevention of memory deficits and a
decrease in anxiety levels by controlling oxidative stress and inflammatory
processes (Esfandiari et al. 2018). L. palustre extract reduced serum uric acid levels in patients with
gouty arthritis and hyperuricemia (Singh et
al. 2021). S. nigra flavonoids prevented H1N1 infection in vitro by
binding to H1N1 virions, blocking host cell entry (Roschek et al. 2009). Fermented leaf extracts of B. crassifolia significantly improved glucose
tolerance and reduced serum triglyceride levels in rats (Shikov et al. 2012). Antioxidant and antitumor activity of C.
cyanus extract was studied on a colon cancer cell line (HT29). The
results of the experiment showed that the extract has a significant
antibacterial and anticancer effect (Escher et
al. 2018). The
results of an experiment in a mouse model of restraint stress showed that
treatment with P. aviculare reduced fatigue, suppressed
neuroinflammation and expression of hormones associated with fatigue (Park et al. 2018). Hypericin
contained in H. perforatum improved
the viability of liver cells by reducing apoptosis and attenuated lipid
accumulation in hepatocytes (Liang et al. 2020). M. officinalis
improved brain tissue health in rats with cerebral ischemia by reducing
cerebral thrombosis, oxidative stress, and inflammatory mediators (Zhao et al. 2017) Aqueous extracts of I.
helenium exhibited antiproliferative and cytotoxic activity, and it can be considered
as a potential antitumor agent for brain cancer (Koc et al. 2018). The research results indicate that the hydroalcoholic extract of C. officinalis flowers in the study of diabetes
mellitus reduced the concentration of insulin and restored the functions of
beta cells (Ebrahimi et al. 2019). Methanol extracts of A. millefolium had a high antioxidant
activity and reduced the strong inhibition of lipid peroxidation. This suggests
potential use as a therapy for neurodegenerative conditions such as Alzheimer's
disease (Barut et al. 2017). There is an assumption
that T. serpyllum has antihyperlipidemic and
hepatoprotective effects (Mushtaq 2017). The extract of C. majus altered the expression of genes associated with apoptosis
and induced apoptosis in hematopoietic cells (Och et
al. 2019). An in
vivo evaluation study of S. officinālis in mice with induced Alzheimer's
disease found that this extract at 300 mg/kg significantly reduced elevated
levels of lipid peroxidation enzymes and also significantly increased levels of
antioxidants in brain tissue, making it effective against Alzheimer's disease
(Datta and Patil 2020).
A critical assessment of the literature on the medicinal properties of
the found plants irrefutably shows that they have a huge therapeutic potential.
But, due to natural habitat conditions – growing in hard-to-reach, swampy
places and in alpine conditions, as well as local or scattered growth – they do
not form thickets of commercial value in nature.
Plant sources have a long history of medicinal use. Herbs have been
invariable sources of both protective and therapeutic traditional medicine
preparations for people since ancient times. The World Health Organization
forecasted that about 60% of the worlds inhabitants in developing countries
trust herbs for curing a variety of illnesses, owing to the lack of modern
healthcare resources. The use of traditional medicines is usually influenced by
the availability and acceptability of medical services. Medicinal plants,
especially in remote regions of developing countries, may be the only source of
health available (Karakaya et al. 2020). Therefore, many
developing countries are studying the biodiversity of local plants, searching
for new sources of phytoactive substances. Research on the public knowledge of
local medicinal plants is also being conducted (Aworinde and Erinoso 2015).
The analysis of our survey of two age groups showed that the older
generation (35–55 years old) is more aware of plant species with antibiotic
properties and is more willing to choose natural herbs as medicines. The other
group (18–25 years old) recognizes only banal plant species that are part of
well-known syrups and lozenges for colds, and prefers pharmacological
preparations, the use of which does not take time to prepare. This indicates
the incomplete formation of survival knowledge among the younger generation
living in Central Kazakhstan. Fundamental survival knowledge includes knowledge
of medicinal plants, food plants and hunting strategies. This requires considerable
social research.
Conclusion
Based on the
above data, it can be concluded that a sufficient number of plants with
antibiotic properties grow in the territory of Central Kazakhstan. Reportedly,
these plants hold great promise for further study of their medicinal properties
and their use as medicines. Given their low cost and availability, we believe
that they need to be popularized among the younger generation and recommended
for commercial use.
Author Contributions
Pozdnyakova
Yelena participated in an expedition to collect and identify plants, wrote a
manuscript. Omarova Gulnara participated in an expedition to collect and
identify plants, did a literature search. Murzatayeva Aigul participated in an
expedition to collect and identify plants, translated the manuscript.
Conflicts of Interest
All authors
declare no conflict of interest.
Data Availability
Data presented in this study will be available on a fair
request to the corresponding author.
Ethics Approval
Not applicable
in this paper
References
Aćimović
M, B Lončar, B Kiprovski, J Jeremić, M Todosijević, L Pezo, J
Jelena (2021a). Chamomile essential oil quality after postharvest separation
treatments. Ratari Povrt 58:72‒78
Aćimović
M, A Varga, M Cvetković, P Lato, B Lončar, M Ignjatov, T Zeremski
(2021). The chemical composition of the essential oil of myrrh variety "Domachi
lyubyushchie" and evaluation of antimicrobial activity. Ratari
Povrt 58:23–30
Ak G, G
Zengin, R Ceylan (2021). Chemical composition and biological activities of
essential oils from Calendula officinalis L. flowers and leaves. Flavour
Fragr J 36:554‒563
Akzhigitova ZH,
MA Dyusebaeva, T Tokay, A Ydyrys, X Lijiang, J Jenis (2020). Phytochemical
study of Bergenia crassifolia. Chem Nat Compd 56:912‒914
Akram M, M
Riaz, N Munir, A Rasul, M Daniyal, SM Ali Shah, MA Shariati, G Shaheen, N
Akhtar, F Parveen, N Akhter, A Owais Ghauri, AW Chishti, M Usman Sarwar, F Said
Khan (2020). Progress and prospects in the management of bacterial infections
and developments in phytotherapeutic modalities. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol
47:1107‒1119
Ali SI, B
Gopalakrishnan, V Venkatesalu (2018). Chicory (Cichorium intybus) and wormwood
(Artemisia absinthium) extracts exhibit strong larvicidal activity
against mosquito vectors of malaria, dengue fever and filariasis. Parasitol
Intl 67:781‒786
Alibi S, W Ben
Selma, J Ramos-Vivas, MA Smach, R Touati, J Boukadida, J Navas H, Ben Mansour
(2020). Anti-oxidant, antibacterial, anti-biofilm, and anti-quorum sensing
activities of four essential oils against multidrug-resistant bacterial
clinical isolates. Curr Res Transl Med 68:59‒66
Almanea A, GSA
El-Aziz, MMM Ahmed (2019). The Potential gastrointestinal health benefits of Thymus
vulgaris essential oil: A review. Biomed Pharmacol J 12:1793‒179
Amraei M, E
Shirzadpour, M Mohamadpour, SF Mousavi, A Ghorbani (2018). Surveying
antioxidant activity of hydroalcoholic extract of Matricaria chamomilla
L. and comparing it to lovastatin in rat. Asian J Pharmaceut 12:1527‒1530
Ansari S, M
Siddiqui, S Malhotra, M Maaz (2018). Antiviral efficacy of qust (Saussurea
lappa) and afsanteen (Artemisia absinthium) for chronic hepatitis B:
A prospective single-arm pilot clinical trial. Pharmacog Res 10:282‒290
Arora D, A
Sharma (2013). A review on phytochemical and pharmacological potential of genus
Chelidonium. Pharmacog J 5:184‒190
Ayaz M, M
Junaid, F Ullah, A Sadiq, M Ovais, W Ahmad, S Аhmad, A Zeb (2016).
Chemical profiling, antimicrobial and insecticidal evaluations of Polygonum
hydropiper L. BMC Complimentary
Altern Med 16:502
Aworinde D, S
Erinoso (2015). Ethnobotanical investigation of indigenous plants used in the
management of some infant illnesses in Ibadan, South-Western Nigeria. Afr J
Trad Complem Altern Med 12:9
Bianco A, F
Licata, R Zucco, R Papadopoli, M Pavia (2020). Knowledge and practices
regarding antibiotics use: Findings from a cross-sectional survey among Italian
adults. Evol Med Public Health 2020:129‒138
Bhukta P, D
Rath, G Pattnaik, B Kar, SK Ranajit (2021). A comprehensive review on promising
phytopharmacological applications of chamomile flower. Asian J Chem 33:2864‒2870
Benedek B, N
Gjoncaj, J Saukel, B Kopp (2007). Distribution of phenolic compounds in Middle
European taxa of the Achillea millefolium L. aggregate. Chem Biodivers 4:849‒857
Belwal T, HP
Devkota, MK Singh, R Sharma, S
Upadhayay, C Joshi, Kl Bisht (2019). St. John’s Wort (Hypericum
perforatum). In: Nonvitamin
and Nonmineral Nutritional Supplements, pp:415‒432. Elsevier,
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Bai LM, J
Wang, ML Fu, S Han, JH Pang, WZ Zhang (2018). Chemical constituents from Inula
helenium. Chin Trad Herbal Drugs 49:2512‒2518
Baitenov M
(1999). Flora of Kazakhstan. Vol: 1., Ġylym Press, Almaty, Kazakhstan
Baitenov M
(2001). Flora of Kazakhstan. Ancestral complex of flora. Vol: 2., Ġylym
Press, Almaty, Kazakhstan
Barut EN, B
Barut, S Engin, S Yıldırım, A Yaşar, S Türkiş, A Özel,
F Sezen (2017). Antioxidant capacity, anti-acetylcholinesterase activity and
inhibitory effect on lipid peroxidation in mice brain homogenate of Achillea
millefolium. Turk J Biochem 42:493‒502
Beheshti-Rouy
M, M Azarsina, L Rezaie-Soufi, MY Alikhani, G Roshanaie, S Komaki (2015). The
antibacterial effect of sage extract (Salvia officinalis) mouthwash
against Streptococcus mutans in dental plaque: a randomized clinical
trial. Iran J Microbiol 7:173‒177
Boucher MA, H
Côté, A Pichette, L Ripoll, J Legault (2020). Chemical composition and
antibacterial activity of Tussilago farfara (L.) essential oil from
Quebec, Canada. Nat Prod Res 34:545‒548
Chen H, I
Muhammad, Y Zhang, X Huang, L Diao, H Liu, X Li, X Sun, G
Abbas, G Li (2019). Antiviral activity against infectious bronchitis
virus and bioactive components of Hypericum perforatum L. Front
Pharmacol 10:1272
Czinner E, É
Lemberkovics, E Bihátsi-Karsai, G Vitányi, L Lelik (2000). Composition of the
Essential Oil from the Inflorescence of Helichrysum arenarium (L.)
Moench. J Essen Oil Res 12:728‒730
Citová I, M
Ganzera, H Stuppner, P Solich (2008). Determination of gentisin, isogentisin,
and amarogentin in Gentiana lutea L. by capillary electrophoresis. J
Sep Sci 31:195‒200
Chellakannu MT,
R Paneerselvam (2020). Acorus calamus and its biomedical applications –
review. Plant Cell Biotechnol Mol Biol 21:49‒57
Coss E, C
Kealey, D Brady, P Walsh (2018). A laboratory investigation of the
antimicrobial activity of a selection of western phytomedicinal tinctures. Eur
J Integr Med 19:80‒83
Dampc A, M
Luczkiewicz (2013). Rhododendron tomentosum (Ledum palustre). A
review of traditional use based on current research. Fitoterapia 85:130‒143
Datta S, Patil
S (2020). Evaluation of traditional herb extract Salvia officinalis in
treatment of Alzheimers disease. Pharmacog J 12:131‒143
Dias MI, L
Barros, M Dueńas, E Pereira, AM Carvalho, RC Alves, MB Oliveira, C
Santos-Buelga, IC Ferreira (2013). Chemical composition of wild and commercial Achillea
millefolium L. and bioactivity of the methanolic extract, infusion and
decoction. Food Chem 141:4152‒4160
De Oliveira
JR, PG das Figueiredo Vilela Vilela, RB de Almeida, FE de Oliveira, CAT
Carvalho, SEA Camargo, AOC Jorge, LD de Oliveira (2019). Antimicrobial activity
of noncytotoxic concentrations of Salvia officinalis extract against bacterial
and fungal species from the oral cavity. Gen
Dentistry 67:22‒26
De Santis F, N
Poerio, A Gismondi, V Nanni, G Di Marco, R Nisini, MC Thaller, A Canini, M
Fraziano (2019). Hydroalcoholic extract from Origanum vulgare induces a
combined anti-mycobacterial and anti-inflammatory response in innate immune
cells. PLoS One 14:e0213150
Desam NR, AJ
Al-Rajab, M Sharma, MM Mylabathula, RR Gowkanapalli, M Albratty (2019).
Chemical constituents, in vitro antibacterial and antifungal activity of Mentha
× piperita L. (peppermint) essential oils. J King Saud Univ Sci
31:528‒533
Doğan
Ş, B Gökalsın, İ Şenkardeş, A Doğan, NC Sesal
(2019). Anti-quorum sensing and anti-biofilm activities of Hypericum
perforatum extracts against Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J
Ethnopharmacol 235:293‒300
Ebrahimi E, A
Kheirollah, E Mansouri, H Babaahmadi-Rezaei, G Mohammadzadeh (2019). Effects of
hydroalcoholic flower extract of marigold (Calendula officinalis) on the
biochemical and histological parameters in STZ-induced diabetic rats. Jundishapur
J Nat Pharm Prod 14:e55456
Escher GB, JS
Santos, ND Rosso, MB Marques, L Azevedo, MAV do Carmo, H Daguer, L Molognoni,
LD Prado-Silva, AS Sant'Ana, MC da Silva, D Granato (2018). Chemical study,
antioxidant, anti-hypertensive, and cytotoxic/cytoprotective activities of Centaurea
cyanus L. petals aqueous extract. Food Chem Toxicol 118:439‒453
Esfandiari E,
M Ghanadian, B Rashidi, A Mokhtarian, AM Vatankhah (2018). The effects of Acorus
calamus L. in preventing memory loss, anxiety, and oxidative stress on
lipopolysaccharide-induced neuroinflammation rat models. Intl J Prev Med
9:85
Fernandez A, I
Cock (2016). The therapeutic properties of Juniperus communis L.:
Antioxidant capacity, bacterial growth inhibition, anticancer activity and
toxicity. J Pharmacog 8:273‒280
Fierascu I, C
Ungureanu, SM Avramescu, C Cimpeanu, MI Georgescu, RC Fierascu, A Ortan, AN
Sutan, V Anuta, A Zanfirescu, CE Dinu-Pirvu, BS Velescu (2018). Genoprotective,
antioxidant, antifungal and anti-inflammatory evaluation of hydroalcoholic
extract of wild-growing Juniperus communis L. (Cupressaceae) native to
Romanian southern sub-Carpathian hills. BMC Complem Altern Med 18:3
Ghosh A, S
Saha (2020). Survey of drug resistance associated gene mutations in Mycobacterium
tuberculosis, ESKAPE and other bacterial species. Sci Rep 10:8957
Gierlikowska
B, W Gierlikowski, K Bekier, K Skalicka-Woźniak, ME Czerwińska, AK
Kiss (2020). Inula helenium and Grindelia squarrosa as a source
of compounds with anti-inflammatory activity in human neutrophils and cultured
human respiratory epithelium. J Ethnopharmacol 249:112311
Gründemann C,
CW Gruber, A Hertrampf, M Zehl, B Kopp, R Huber (2011). An aqueous birch leaf
extract of Betula pendula inhibits the growth and cell division of
inflammatory lymphocytes. J Ethnopharmacol 136:444‒451
Hajisalem T, S
Ghaffary, B Nejati, S Mashayekhi, F Fathiazad, J Shokri, A Bateni (2019).
Effect of Achillea millefolium mouthwash on oral mucositis induced by
chemotherapy in AML patients. Jundishapur J Nat Pharmaceut Prod 14:e14077
Hameed IH, HJ
Hussein, MY Hadi (2018). Cytotoxic activity of Thymus vulgaris:
Antibacterial and antifungal activity. Intl J Pharmaceut Qual Assur 9:166‒169
Haziri A, F
Faiku, I Rudhani, I Mehmeti, D Motori (2017). Antibacterial activity of
different extracts of Centaurea cyanus (L.) growing wild in Kosovo. Oriental
J Chem 33:1636‒1641
Ickovski J, O
Jovanovic, B Zlatkovic (2021). Variations in the composition of essential oils
of selected Artemisia species as a function of soil type. J Serb Chem
Soc 86:1259‒1269
Jiang M, BW
Cui, YL Wu, JX Nan, LH Lian (2021). Genus Gentiana: A review on
phytochemistry, pharmacology and molecular mechanism. J Ethnopharmacol 264:113391
Karaganda Region
Encyclopedia (1986). Kazakh Soviet Encyclopedia. Nurgaliev RN (ed.). Karaganda,
Kazakhstan
Karakaya S, A
Polat, Ö Aksakal, YZ Sümbüllü, Ü Incekara (2020). Ethnobotanical study of
medicinal plants in Aziziye District (Erzurum, Turkey). Turk J Pharm Sci
17:211–220
Khosroyar S, A
Arastehnodeh (2018). Comparison of anti-inflammatory and antioxidant capacity
of alcholic extraction of fraxinus fxcelsior and Melilotus officinalis
plant. Plant Arch 18:443‒448
Kinoshita E, K
Hayashi, H Katayama, T Hayashi, A Obata (2012). Anti-influenza virus effects of
elderberry juice and its fractions. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem 76:1633‒1638
Koc K, O
Ozdemir, A Ozdemir, U Dogru, H Turkez (2018). Antioxidant and anticancer
activities of extract of Inula helenium (L.) in human U-87 MG
glioblastoma cell line. J Cancer Res Ther 14:658‒661
Kosikowska U,
M Wegiera, H Smolarz, A Malm (2011). Screening of antifungal activity of Rumex
L. species. Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Sklodowska, Sectio DDD:
Pharmacia 24:99‒104
Koyuncu I
(2018). Evaluation of anticancer, antioxidant activity and phenolic compounds of Artemisia absinthium L. extract. Cell Mol
Biol 64:25‒34
Laila U, M
Akram, MA Shariati, AM Hashmi, N Akhtar, IM Tahir, AO Ghauri, N Munir, M Riaz,
N Akhter, G Shaheen, Q Ullah, R Zahid, S Ahmad (2019). Role of medicinal plants
in HIV/AIDS therapy. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 46:1063‒1073
Leonidovna SN, TD Alexandrovich, BK Nikolayevna, GS
Kamilevna, LA Pavlovna, F Igor'Mikhaylovich, BT Gennad'yevich (2019).
Phytochemical contents, antimicrobial and antioxidant properties of Gnaphalium
uliginosum L. ethanolic extract and essential oil for agricultural uses. Asian J Chem 31:2672‒2678
Liang C, Y Li,
M Bai, Y Huang, H Yang, L Liu, S Wang, C Yu, Z Song, Y Bao, J Yi, L Sun, Y Li
(2020). Hypericin attenuates nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and abnormal
lipid metabolism via the PKA-mediated AMPK signaling pathway in vitro
and in vivo. Pharmacol Res 153:104657
Liu C, H Wu, L
Wang, H Luo, Y Lu, Q
Zhang, L Tang, Z Wang (2020). Farfarae Flos: A review of botany, traditional
uses, phytochemistry, pharmacology and toxicology. J Ethnopharmacol 260:113038
Lockowandt L,
J Pinela, CL Roriz, C Pereira, RM Abre, RC Calhelha, MJ Alves, L Barros M,
Bredol, IC Ferreira (2019). Chemical features and bioactivities of cornflower (Centaurea
cyanus L.) capitula: The blue flowers and the unexplored non-edible part. Indust
Crops Prod 128:496‒503
Lunz K, I
Stappen (2021). Back to the Roots—An overview of the chemical composition and
bioactivity of selected root-essential oils. Molecules 26:3155
Lyles JT, A
Kim, K Nelson, AL Bullard-Roberts, A Hajdari, B Mustafa, CL Quave (2017). The
chemical and antibacterial evaluation of St. John’s Wort oil macerates used in
Kosovar traditional medicine. Front Microbiol 8:163
Malankina EL,
LN Kozlovskaya, AN Kuzmenko, AA Evgrafov (2019). Determination of the component
composition of essential oil of thyme species by the method of gas
chromatography. Moscow Univ Chem Bull 74:310‒314
Millar BC, JR
Rao, JE Moore (2021). Fighting antimicrobial resistance (AMR): Chinese herbal
medicine as a source of novel antimicrobials – an update. Lett Appl
Microbiol 73:400‒407
Mlcek J, A
Plaskova, T Jurikova, J Sochor, M Baron, S Ercisli (2021). Chemical,
nutritional and sensory characteristics of six ornamental edible flowers
species. Foods 10:2053
Moghrovyan A,
N Sahakyan, A Babayan, N Chichoyan, M Petrosyan, A Trchounian (2019). Essential
oil and ethanol extract of oregano (Origanum vulgare L.) from Armenian
flora as a natural source of terpenes, flavonoids and other phytochemicals with
antiradical, antioxidant, metal chelating, tyrosinase inhibitory and
antibacterial activity. Curr Pharm Des 25:1809‒1816
Mohammed GJ,
IH Hameed (2018). Anti-fungal, antitumor and anti-inflammatory activity of Acorus calamus. Ind J Publ Health Res
Dev 9:254
Mohammed R, F
Musa, Y Mehdi, A Al-Rawe (2020). Impacts of the alcoholic extract and essential
oil of Thymus vulgaris L. against the causative agent of acne formation
(Staphylococcus aureus). System Rev Pharm 11:498
Mojicevic M,
PM D’Agostino, J Nikodinovic-Runic, B Vasiljevic, TAM Gulder, S Vojnovic
(2019). Antifungal potential of bacterial rhizosphere isolates associated with
three ethno-medicinal plants (poppy, chamomile, and nettle). Intl Microbiol
22:343‒353
Morikawa T, LB
Wang, S Nakamura, K Ninomiya, E Yokoyama, H Matsuda, O Muraoka, LJ Wu, M
Yoshikawa (2009). Medicinal flowers. XXVII. New flavanone and chalcone
glycosides, arenariumosides I, II, III, and IV, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha
inhibitors from everlasting, flowers of Helichrysum arenarium. Chem
Pharm Bull 57:361‒367
Motiee M
(2021). Changes in essential oil composition of peppermint (Mentha x
piperita L.) affected by yeast extract and salicylic acid foliar application.
J Med Plants 20:47‒58
Mushtaq MN
(2017). Effect of aqueous extract of Thymus serpyllum on lipid profile
and some liver enzymes in alloxan-induced diabetic rabbit. Bangl J Pharmacol
12:58
Najafi MN
(2019). Herbal medicines against bacterial vaginosis in women of reproductive
age: A systematic review. Farmacia 67:931‒940
Nawrot J, M
Wilk-Jędrusik, S Nawrot, K Nawrot, B Wilk, R Dawid-Pać, M
Urbańska, I Micek, G Nowak, J Gornowicz-Porowska (2020). Milky sap of
greater celandine (Chelidonium majus L.) and anti-viral properties. Intl
J Environ Res Public Health 17:E1540
Nayak D, S
Ashe, P Ranjan Rauta, B Nayak (2017). Assessment of antioxidant, antimicrobial
and anti-osteosarcoma potential of four traditionally used Indian medicinal
plants. J Appl Biomed 15:119‒132
Nikolić
M, J Glamočlija, ICFR Ferreira, RC Calhelha, Â Fernandes, T Marković,
D Marković, A Giweli, M Soković (2014). Chemical composition, antimicrobial,
antioxidant and antitumor activity of Thymus serpyllum L., Thymus
algeriensis Boiss. and Reut and Thymus vulgaris L. essential oils. Indust
Crops Prod 52:183‒190
Nile SH, DH
Kim, A Nile, GS Park, E Gansukh, G Kai (2020). Probing the effect of quercetin
3-glucoside from Dianthus superbus L. against influenza virus infection-
In vitro and in silico biochemical and toxicological screening. Food
Chem Toxicol 135:110985
Och A, D
Zalewski Ł, Komsta, P Kołodziej, J Kocki, A Bogucka-Kocka (2019).
Cytotoxic and proapoptotic activity of sanguinarine, berberine, and extracts of
Chelidonium majus L. and Berberis thunbergii DC. toward
hematopoietic cancer cell lines. Toxins 11:E485
Olennikov DN,
NK Chirikova, NI Kashchenko (2015). Spinacetin: A aew caffeoylglycoside, and
other phenolic compounds from Gnaphalium uliginosum. Chem Nat Comp
51:1085‒1090
Orav A, M
Koel, T Kailas, M Müürisepp (2010). Comparative analysis of the composition of
essential oils and supercritical carbon dioxide extracts from the berries and
needles of Estonian juniper (Juniperus communis L.). Proc Chem 2:161‒167
Park SH, S
Jang, E Son, SW Lee, SD Park, YY Sung, HK Kim (2018). Polygonum aviculare
L. extract reduces fatigue by inhibiting neuroinflammation in
restraint-stressed mice. Phytomedicine 42:180‒189
Parente LML,
RS Lino Júnior, LMF Tresvenzol, MC Vinaud, JR de Paula, NM Paulo (2012). Wound
healing and anti-inflammatory effect in animal models of Calendula
officinalis L. growing in Brazil. Evid Based Compl Altern Med 2012:375671
Penkov D, V
Andonova, D Delev, I Kostadinov, M Kassarova (2018). Antioxidant activity of
dry birch (Betula pendula) leaves extract. Folia Med 60:571‒579
Pljevljakušić
D, D Bigović, T Janković, S Jelačić, K Šavikin (2018).
Sandy everlasting (Helichrysum arenarium (L.) moench): botanical,
chemical and biological properties. Front Plant Sci 9:1123
Popa CL, A
Lupitu, MD Mot, L Copolovici, C Moisa, DM Copolovici (2021). Chemical and
biochemical characterization of essential oils and their corresponding
hydrolats from six species of the Lamiaceae family. Plants 10:2489
Przybylska-Balcerek
A, T Szablewski, L Szwajkowska-Michałek, D Świerk, R
Cegielska-Radziejewska, Z Krejpcio, E Suchowilska, Ł Tomczyk, K
Stuper-Szablewska (2021). Sambucus nigra extracts–natural antioxidants
and antimicrobial compounds. Molecules 26:2910
Radojković
M, M Vujanović, T Majkić, G Zengin, I Beara, M Catauro, D Montesano
(2021). Evaluation of Sambucus nigra L. Biopotential as an unused
natural resource. Appl Sci 11:11207
Rastogi S, MM
Pandey, RA Kumar Singh (2015). Medicinal plants of the genus Betula –
traditional uses and a phytochemical–pharmacological review. J
Ethnopharmacol 159:62‒83
Rawson TM, D
Ming, R Ahmad, LSP Moore, AH Holmes (2020). Antimicrobial use, drug-resistant
infections and COVID-19. Nat Rev Microbiol 18:409‒410
Roca I, M
Akova, F Baquero, M Cavaleri, S Coenen, J Cohen, D Findlay, I Gyssens, OE
Heuer, G Kahlmeter, H Kruse, R Laxminarayan, E Liébana, L López-Cerero, A
MacGowan, M Martins, J Rodríguez-Bańo, J-M Rolain, C Segovia, B Sigauque, E
Tacconelli, E Wellington, J Vila (2015). The global threat of antimicrobial
resistance: science for intervention. New Microbes New Infect 6:22‒29
Roschek B, RC
Fink, MD McMichael, D Li, RS Alberte (2009). Elderberry flavonoids bind to and
prevent H1N1 infection in vitro. Phytochemistry 70:1255‒1261
Rosmalena R, B
Elya, BE Dewi, F Fithriyah, H Desti, M Angelina, M Hanafi, PD Lotulung, VD
Prasasty, D Seto (2019). The antiviral effect of Indonesian medicinal plant
extracts against dengue virus in vitro and in silico. Pathogens 8:E85
Rusen ID
(2020). Challenges in tuberculosis clinical trials in the face of the COVID-19
pandemic: A sponsor’s perspective. Trop Med 5:86
Safiaghdam H,
V Oveissi, R Bahramsoltani, MH Farzaei, R Rahimi (2018). Medicinal plants for
gingivitis: A review of clinical trials. Iran J Basic Med Sci 21:978‒991
Savikin K, N
Menković, G Zdunić, T Stević, D Radanović, T Janković
(2009). Antimicrobial activity of Gentiana lutea L. extracts. Z
Naturforsch C J Biosci 64:339‒342
Sener B
(2020). Antiviral activity of natural products and herbal extracts. Gazi Med J 31:474‒477
Seo SH, SH
Lee, PH Cha, MY Kim, DS Min, KY Choi (2016). Polygonum aviculare L. and its active compounds, quercitrin
hydrate, caffeic acid, and rutin, activate the Wnt/β-catenin pathway and
induce cutaneous wound healing: Natural compound activate wound healing via
Wnt/β-catenin pathway. Phytother Res 30:848‒854
Seyedjavadi
SS, S Khani, A Eslamifar, S Ajdary, M Goudarzi, R Halabian, R Akbari, H
Zare-Zardini, AAI Fooladi, J Amani, M Razzaghi-Abyaneh (2019). The antifungal
peptide MCH-AMP1 derived from Matricaria chamomilla inhibits Candida
albicans growth via inducing ROS generation and altering fungal cell
membrane permeability. Front Microbiol 10:3150
Sharifi-Rad M,
J Nazaruk, L Polito, MFB Morais-Braga, JE Rocha, HDM Coutinho, B Salehi, G
Tabanelli, C Montanari, M Del Mar Contreras, Z Yousaf, WN Setzer, DR Verma, M
Martorell, A Sureda, J Sharifi-Rad (2018). Matricaria genus as a source
of antimicrobial agents: From farm to pharmacy and food applications. Microbiol
Res 215:76‒88
Shikov AN, M
Kundracikova, TL Palama, ON Pozharitskaya, VM Kosman, VG Makarov, B Galambosi,
HJ Kim, YP Jang, YH Choi, R Verpoorte (2010). Phenolic constituents of Gnaphalium
uliginosum L. Phytochem Lett 3:45‒47
Shikov AN, ON
Pozharitskaya, MN Makarova, M
Kovaleva, I Laakso, HJ Dorman, R Hiltunen, VG Makaro, B Galambosi (2012).
Effect of Bergenia crassifolia L. extracts on weight gain and feeding
behavior of rats with high-caloric diet-induced obesity. Phytomedicine 19:1250‒1255
Singh B, J
Gupta, R Mohan, R Gupta, K Pal (2021). Hypouricemic significance of Ledum
palustre (Marsh Tea): A review. Res J Pharm Technol 14:2907‒2912
Sisay M, WE
Mammo, E Yaya (2021). Phytochemical studies of Melilotus officinalis. Bull
Chem Soc Eth 35:141‒150
Skvortsova VV,
NA Navolokin, NV Polukonova, EV Manaenkova, LÉ Pankratova, MA Kurchatova, GN
Masliakova, NA Durnova (2015). Antituberculous in vitro activity of Helichrýsum
arenárium extract. Eksp Klin Farmakol
78:30‒33
Szopa A, J
Pajor, P Klin, A Rzepiela, HO
Elansary, FA Al-Mana, MA Mattar, H Ekiert (2020). Artemisia
absinthium L. – importance in the history of medicine, the latest advances
in phytochemistry and therapeutical, cosmetological and culinary uses. Plants
9:1063
State Register
of Medicines of the Republic of Kazakhstan (2021). Russian. Available at:
https://www.ndda.kz/category/gos_reestr_excel / (Accessed: 20 October 2021)
Tacconelli E,
E Carrara, A Savoldi, S Harbarth, M Mendelson, DL Monnet, C Pulcini, G
Kahlmeter, J Kluytmans, Y Carmeli, M Ouellette, K Outterson, J Patel, M
Cavaleri, EM Cox, CR Houchens, ML Grayson, P Hansen, N Singh, U Theuretzbacher,
N Magrini (2018). WHO pathogens priority list working group. Discovery,
research, and development of new antibiotics: the WHO priority list of
antibiotic-resistant bacteria and tuberculosis. Lancet Infect Dis 18:318‒327
Tolmacheva AA,
EA Rogozhin, DG Deryabin (2014). Antibacterial and quorum sensing regulatory
activities of some traditional Eastern-European medicinal plants. Acta Pharm
64:173‒186
Torabian G, P
Valtchev, Q Adil, F Dehghani (2019). Anti-influenza activity of elderberry (Sambucus
nigra). J Funct Foods 54:353‒360
Tumova L, H
Endrychová, D Vokurková (2018). Immunostimulant activity of Bergenia
extracts. Phcog Mag 14:328
Turkmen M
(2021). Chemical composition of the essential oils of Salvia Spp.
leaves. Bangl J Bot 50:1173‒1180
Tynybekov BM,
YA Litvinenko, GA Mukanova, GK Satybaldiyeva, NB Baimurzayev, NT Ablaikhanova,
AT Kuatbayev, SE Sharakhmetov (2013). Phytochemical investigation of the roots
of Rumex confertus W. grown in the culture. World Appl Sci J 26:941‒944
Uysal S, I
Senkardes, A Mollica (2019). Biologically active compounds from two members of
the Asteraceae family: Tragopogon dubius Scop. and Tussilago farfara
L. J Biomol Str Dyn 37:3269‒3281
Wegiera M, U
Kosikowska, A Malm, H Smolarz (2011). Antimicrobial activity of the extracts
from fruits of Rumex L. species. Cent Eur J Biol 6:1036‒1043
Wesolowska A, D
Grzeszczuk Jadczak, P Nawrotek, M Struk (2015). Comparison of the chemical
composition and antimicrobial activity of Thymus serpyllum essential
oils. Not Bot Hortic Agrobot 43:432‒438
WHO (2017).
Global priority list of antibiotic-resistant bacteria to guide research,
discovery, and development of new antibiotics. Available at: https://www.who.int/medicines/publications/global-priority-list-antibiotic-resistant-bacteria/en/
( Accessed 13 March 2022)
World Health
Organization Antimicrobial Resistance (2014). Global Report on Surveillance,
2014. Available at: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/112642/1/9789241564748_eng.pdf./
(Accessed: 20 October 2021)
Wu Z, B Tan, Y
Liu, J Dunn, GP Martorell, M Tortajada, Z Cao, P Ji (2019). Chemical
composition and antioxidant properties of essential oils from peppermint,
native spearmint and scotch spearmint. Molecules 24:2825
Yang Y, W
Zhang, Z Xie, J Lei, J Yu (2017). Constituents of Dianthus superbus and
their cytotoxic activity. Chem Nat Comp 53:740‒741
Żbikowska B, R Franiczek, A
Sowa, G Połukord, B Krzyżanowska, Z Sroka (2017). Antimicrobial and
antiradical activity of extracts obtained from leaves of five species of the
genus Bergenia: Identification of antimicrobial compounds. Microb
Drug Resist 23:771‒780
Zhao Y, YH
Yang, M Ye, KB Wang, LM Fan, FW Su (2021). Chemical composition and antifungal
activity of essential oil from Origanum vulgare against Botrytis
cinerea. Food Chem 365:130506
Zhao GC, YL
Yuan, FR Chai, FJ Ji (2017). Effect of Melilotus officinalis extract on
the apoptosis of brain tissues by altering cerebral thrombosis and inflammatory
mediators in acute cerebral ischemia. Biomed Pharmacother 89:1346‒1352